Elements tested
CPEG3
CPEG3H
CPEG3HT
CPEG3T
CPEG4
CPEG4H
CPEG4HT
CPEG4I
CPEG4IH
CPEG4R
CPEG4RH
CPEG4RHT
CPEG4RT
CPEG4T
CPEG6
CPEG6H
CPEG6M
CPEG6MH
CPEG6MHT
CPEG6MT
CPEG8
CPEG8H
CPEG8HT
CPEG8R
CPEG8RH
CPEG8RHT
CPEG8T
ProductsAbaqus/Standard Elements testedCPEG3 CPEG3H CPEG3HT CPEG3T CPEG4 CPEG4H CPEG4HT CPEG4I CPEG4IH CPEG4R CPEG4RH CPEG4RHT CPEG4RT CPEG4T CPEG6 CPEG6H CPEG6M CPEG6MH CPEG6MHT CPEG6MT CPEG8 CPEG8H CPEG8HT CPEG8R CPEG8RH CPEG8RHT CPEG8T Problem descriptionMaterial:Linear elastic, Young's modulus = 30 × 106, Poisson's ratio = 0.3. Boundary conditions:. Step 1 (Perturbation)An out-of-plane displacement of 0.01 units (motion of one bounding plane relative to the other) is applied to degree of freedom 3 of the reference node, which is the change in fiber length degree of freedom.
Step 2 (Perturbation)A relative rotation of 0.01 radians about the y-axis is applied to degree of freedom 5 of the reference node (the rotation degree of freedom of one bounding plane relative to the other).
Results and discussionFor Step 1, all element types yield the exact solution. The results for Step 2 are given in the following table:
Second-order quadrilateral elements, first-order incompatible mode elements, and quadratic triangles yield the exact solutions. Modified triangles yield nearly exact solutions. Other element types exhibit stiff response. Input files
|